>>
|
No. 11204
[Edit]
>>11201
Better - yes, good - not really. Lots of these are still completely forced and plain don't work. Sigh, let's go series by series.
Lucky Star - okay, mostly because it might be the first series that people tried to clasify in this way (along with Azumanga, Mashimaro and maybe Hidamari, I think that's what these charts used to look like when I first saw them)
Even then we've got the first problem already. All characters that get classified as boke could be clasified as the genki girl at the same time. The thing is all characters in the 'moe through helplessness' group are comparatevily more boke than real bokes. Who is more boke between Matsuri and Miu and between Tomo and Osaka? Characters from the first group tend to be just stupid. When you look at 'moe through helplessness' characters you sometimes have to question whether they were born on planet Earth.
Now, if you were rename those groups you'd end up with 'genki boke' and 'stoner boke'. You'd have those two and tsukkomi. Guess what, you classified 3/4 characters based on their role in manzai routine. The differences between the characters themselves are still big.
It's almost as stupid as using only two groups (boke and tsukommi) and claiming every single show that ever had any comedy elements follows the same formula when it comes to creating characters.
If you were to look at their personalities only I'd say Sae and Sakaki are similar and so are Yuno and Chiyo. However their roles in the show (and positions on the chart) are completely different. Which is precisely why these charts are stupid.
Mashimaro - I can live with that
Hidamari - Sae isn't much of a tsukkomi
Azumanga - Sakaki would be a better fit for the 4th category
Clannad - never seen the anime, played a bit of the VN, I think that Mamiko Noto girl is a better fit for the third category; also KEY
Air - KEY, I hate KEY
Kannon - KEY, I hate KEY; note - no fucking point in classifying KEY series along with the rest of these, it's a completely different genre
Natsuiro - Rinko just doesn't fit. She's hardly 'helpless', she keeps taking care of Yuka all the time. Saki is more of a tsukkomi character than what's-her-name-again (Natsume?).
Accel World - haven't seen it
Yuru Yuri - can you fail any harder? Yui as anything but tsukkomi is the most retarded thing on the whole chart.
Milky Holmes - Elly as tsukkomi, come on.
Saki - not bad in all honesty. Classifying the second (? or not? I'm looking at you Sukoyan) biggest raptist in Japan as 'more through helplessness' and Hisa as 'perfect' is a bit off but I can live with that.
A-Channel - I didn't think the baseball bat girl was much of a boke but the rest works.
Tamayura - backlogged for all eternity
Nichijou - haven't seen it
RoKyuBu - okay, works now
|