>>
|
No. 37773
[Edit]
File
170479289019.jpg
- (112.53KB
, 1280x720
, [SubsPlease] Uma Musume - Pretty Derby S3 - 13 (72.jpg
)
Finally got around to finishing season3. Last two episodes were a bit of an improvement but it didn't really make up for what a mess the whole season was. This anime feels like lighting off some fireworks, which turn out to be a dud, only to then let off a little poof at the end. It's disappointing, Season 2 was a big improvement over the first, the game was well made, and the ova was great. I was expecting something better. I went into this wanting to love it but walked away disappointed. I had a feeling early on something was off when Rice shower had that awkward cameo like appearance. Which in hindsight feels like a character that was shoved into a script they weren't meant to be in at the last moment because they're popular. Or how they kept randomly playing what sounded like Mortal Kombat theme at inappropriate times.
There was an over reliance on familiarity with the game for one thing, projects like this should be able to stand on their own. you should feel like you might get more out of it by playing the game, but not like you're missing a lot of important details if you missed some of the content in the game, and for a lot of mobile games keeping up with everything can be like a full time job.
We have new characters that just pop up out of nowhere without so much as a greeting, some who don't get introduced till the second to last ep after awkwardly hanging around all season. In spite of adding a handful of new characters, it still felt very empty due to it's focus on mostly just two characters, and even then more so one of them.
If you have really strong complex characters this can work, but that didn't really feel like the case here. This while all the other characters had so little to say and do they might as well have not been there at all. They're all sadly wasted here. Cheval Grand had a nice role to play near the end (Who's great idea was it to spoil the results of the race in the OP?) but she felt so poorly established over the course of the season, it didn't have the same impact. I hate it when a character gets their life story dumped on you all in one go. You had a full season here full of a lot of nothing. Hell, they could have made Cheval Grand be Kitasan Black's rival instead of Duramente, but that might have made too much sense..
What started out with the friendly rivalry between Kitasan Black and Satono Diamond ended up just being a story of Kitasan pushing herself to her limits, while the story pushes Diamond off to the sidelines and literally writes her out of it for a while. Kitasan was given her own rival for some reason early into the season but that didn't really go anywhere. Likewise the whole dynamic with Nice Nature not only went nowhere but didn't really make much sense. Call me dense but I couldn't understand what Nice's deal was with Kitasan. She looks almost embarrassed or ashamed to be associated with her, at one point didn't even want to deal with her until she was noticed. There was this line about feeling inadequate compared to her but that doesn't seem to really mesh with how she acts.
Then you have the boke character in Goldship going stalker mode and giving Kitasan guidance at the end while acting high and mighty for one of the most retarded girls on the campus.
For a character that loves Tokai Teiou, we sure don't see Kitasan interact much with her in spite of being on the same team. We should have seen something of a baton pass there, but instead she was largely treated like window dressing. Just as we don't see anything at all between Diamond and McQueen.
I think there's a part of me that's disappointed to see all the classic fan favorite characters get completely wasted. I understand the need to let a new generation take the stage, but they just do so little with the few they give us. It's like a whole lot of nothing.
So much of this season just feels like a sloppy poorly put together mess, while being dull and boring and recycling the worst parts of the first season. As generic as they were, Special Week actually feels like a stronger character than Kitasan Black, which is really saying something.
|