I generally try everything each season, so prepare for some mass tl;dr
Ano Natsu - Been pretty decent so far, but I'm not enjoying it as much at this stage as I did with Ano Hana. I know they're not related, but they've got exactly the same staff and general feeling.
Another - Not scary, but still has a good atmosphere. I like Mei.
Danshi Koukousei - Actually pretty funny and generally really entertaining.
Natsume Shi - Just as good as the other seasons.
Chihayafuru - I didn't care about karuta at the beginning of the show, but it's really grown on me.
Amagami SS plus - Not as good as the first season, but still watching
Inu x Boku SS - Really entertaining, with great characters all round. Main girl is really cute. OP and EDs are fantastic.
Kill Me Baby - Cute. First ep was average, but it's since gotten much better.
Recorder to Randoseru - The 'he looks like a molester how hilarious' joke got old on the first episode, and I wish they'd focus on Atsumi. Would have preferred another season of Morita.
Milky Holmes 2 - Best of the season by far. This is the only show I watch as soon as it's available regardless of how I feel or how tired I am.
Black Rock Shooter - Disappointed with the butchered character designs. The OVA's school sections (which I'm watching for) were also much better, in my opinion.
High School DxD - Might drop soon. It's a totally uninteresting fanservice show (which I'm usually fine with), but I don't really like any of the girls, and there's too much terrible plot.
Senhime Zesshou Symphogear - Still quite enjoying this. Would like more development on Hibiki and Miku's relationship, though.
Mouretsu Pirates - Really boring so far. Haven't dropped it yet solely because it's a 2cour, so I have hope that it will get better.
Nisemonogatari - I thought Bakemonogatari was okay when it aired, but I recently rewatched and loved it. I'm loving this all the same.
Papa Kiki - Drama isn't good enough for me to be interested in that, and the character designs are pretty weird (the noses in particular). Watching because it's a 2cour and Miu is cute.
Poyopoyo - It kills 3 minutes with some cat related nonsense.
Rinne no Lagrange - Didn't like it at the beginning, but it's growing on me. I seem to like episodes more when they have less action.
Smile Precure - (*´ｖ`*) It's gonna be a good one.
Area no Kishi - Found it boring, and I give no fucks about football.
Brave10 - Generic shonen with extra BL appeal.
Post edited on 15th Feb 2012, 12:23pm